A Journey Back to Murder in The Girl in Town by Jessica Wren
As I cracked open The Girl in Town, the first in Jessica Wren’s Chesapeake Valley Mystery series, I could feel a familiar tug—growing up in a small town myself, I often wondered what would happen if I had to confront the ghosts of my past. Wren’s novel beautifully encapsulates that delicate interplay of nostalgia and fear, all while weaving an intricate mystery that swiftly pulled me into its embrace.
At the heart of this story is Eve Wicker, a former NSA agent who returns to her hometown after her mother’s tragic murder. Reeling from the trauma of her past yet driven by familial duty, Eve steps into the role of sheriff. As she confronts not only the complexities of her job but also the memories she buried deep, we see a character who is both flawed and fiercely relatable. Wren deftly portrays Eve’s resilience and vulnerability, inviting us to root for her as she navigates old wounds and new threats.
Wren’s writing style is engaging, offering vivid descriptions that capture the haunting beauty of Chesapeake Valley. Her prose flows effortlessly, making it easy to lose track of time while enjoying Eve’s tumultuous journey. The pacing struck me as just right—full of suspense yet allowing ample time for character development, especially in Eve’s dynamic with the town’s enigmatic recluse, Roman Pike. Their chemistry is electric and fraught with tension, adding just the right dash of romance to the unfolding mystery. I found myself particularly invested in their evolving relationship set against a backdrop of danger, revealing layers of both characters in a way that felt genuine and earned.
One of my favorite moments in the story is when Eve confronts the unsettling reality of past relationships, suggesting that the innocent charm of her childhood home can harbor dark secrets. The revelations about Roman’s connection to the murder of his ex-girlfriend added depth to the narrative. Wren’s ability to blend these personal complexities with crime drama left me guessing until the very last page. "In these mountains, the most dangerous creature is an enigma," a quote that resonates throughout the book, perfectly encapsulating the gripping thrill we get from each unexpected turn.
The community of Chesapeake Valley itself is almost a character in its own right, filled with vivid, quirky residents that made me chuckle and shake my head in recognition of small-town life. The balance between charming and troubling gives the narrative an immersive quality, further enhanced by snippets of local lore and rich sensory detail.
I highly recommend The Girl in Town to fans of cozy mysteries and those who appreciate strong female protagonists facing their fears. It’s a perfect weekend read, or a touching reminder of the power of home—alongside its complexities. Whether you’re in it for the suspense, the budding romance, or the backdrop of small-town life, Wren delivers an engaging and entertaining package that left me eagerly anticipating the next book in the series.
So curl up with this thrilling mystery, and let Eve Wicker guide you through the shadows of Chesapeake Valley. It’s a ride worth taking!
You can find The Girl in Town (A Chesapeake Valley Mystery Book 1) here >>






