Book Review: It Ends with Us by Colleen Hoover
When I first heard about It Ends with Us, I was intrigued. How could a book labeled as a love story tackle something as heavy as domestic abuse? Colleen Hoover has always been a polarizing figure in contemporary romance, and with this book, she aimed to explore profound themes, particularly the complexities of love intertwined with trauma. However, while I can appreciate the intention, I find myself wrestling with the actual execution.
The narrative centers on Lily Bloom, a young woman navigating her complicated feelings for Ryle Kincaid, a charismatic neurosurgeon with a dark side. At first glance, Ryle seems charming, charming enough to sweep Lily off her feet. However, as the story progresses, it becomes clear that he harbors deeply ingrained issues stemming from his past. The unfolding of their relationship juxtaposes moments of genuine affection with troubling manipulations and outright violence. Hoover crafts a scenario that forces readers to confront the harsh realities many face, yet I worry about the romanticization woven into the depiction of such a destructive relationship.
One aspect that left me unsettled is how easily readers may overlook Ryle’s abusive tendencies, especially given his occasional acts of kindness. A poignant line resonates with me: “People spend so much time wondering why the women don’t leave. Where are all the people who wonder why the men are even abusive?” This is a crucial critique intertwined within the fabric of the story, which I wish was handled with more nuance. While Hoover’s writing flows smoothly and is often heartfelt, the pacing sometimes felt jarring, particularly when the focus shifted between the gravitas of domestic violence and lighthearted romantic moments that felt misplaced.
Moreover, the portrayal of secondary characters like Atlas raises additional questions. Their childhood romance is initially sweet but becomes clouded by a troubling power dynamic. Hoover attempts to delve into the gray areas of love and trauma, yet I found the execution left much to be desired. The cute quotes and moments intended to evoke sighs of romantic nostalgia felt dissonant against the backdrop of abuse and manipulation.
One of the most significant issues that arise with It Ends with Us is the societal interpretation. Time and again, I’ve encountered readers who romanticize Ryle, viewing him as a misunderstood soul rather than considering the gravity of his actions. Hoover acknowledges the complexity of abusive relationships, yet the narrative often feels like it inadvertently provides an avenue for dismissal of true accountability.
Ultimately, I walked away from It Ends with Us feeling conflicted. It is evident that this book bears a personal weight for Hoover, touching on her experiences and reflections. Still, I can’t help but feel that the care with which the theme was approached could have been more robust. I genuinely hope that readers understand that while love is complicated, abusive behavior cannot be justified or overlooked.
For those who appreciate deep emotional journeys, It Ends with Us offers valuable insights, albeit with caution. However, if you’re looking for a straightforward romance story, you might find yourself in uncomfortable territory. My recommendation? Approach this book with an awareness of its heavier themes and let it serve as a conversation starter about the harsh realities many face in relationships.
Discover more about It Ends with Us (It Ends with Us, #1) on GoodReads >>