Review of Marked (The Boys of Bishop Mountain #1) by M.A. Innes
As a self-proclaimed contemporary romance junkie, I was drawn to Marked primarily by its promise of heat and drama, appealing tropes—and who can resist a billionaire, military, brother’s best friend scenario? With a title like that, how could I possibly pass it up? M.A. Innes presents us with a blend of familiar elements, but this novel leaves readers with more questions than answers, leading to a reading experience that resembles a rollercoaster gone off the rails.
The Heart of the Story
At its core, Marked explores themes of unrequited love, miscommunication, and the hard truths of familial expectations. Jess has been in love with her brother’s best friend, Mark, since childhood. However, their relationship is fraught with complications—a chemistry that simmers but never fully ignites. We see Jess evolve into a firecracker of a woman, determined to carve her path amid her brothers’ plans to sell their deceased parents’ land. Yet, despite her strength, she finds herself ensnared in Mark’s manipulative charm the moment he reappears in her life, offering an overwhelming amount of financial support for her charity in exchange for a temporary affair. Talk about a red flag!
Jess’s character is a high point in the narrative; she’s fiercely independent yet shackled by societal expectations surrounding motherhood. The moment she wrestles with Mark’s conditional love, believing her worth hinges on her ability to bear children, I found myself frustrated. Seriously, why must women’s identities be tied to their reproductive capabilities? Jess deserved better than a love challenge framed around her biology.
The Writing Style and Pacing
Innes’s writing has a straightforward, almost simplistic quality to it, which can be both a blessing and a curse. On one hand, it facilitates easy reading; on the other, it makes for a story that feels rushed at times. The pacing suffers from too many time jumps, leaving the chemistry between Jess and Mark feeling discomfortingly forced. Their moments apart significantly outnumber their shared scenes, making it hard for readers to root for their reunion. The book stumbles into plot holes that leave you scratching your head—like Mark’s mysterious connection to Jess’s brother that supposedly kept them two worlds apart for eight long years.
I found certain elements utterly laughable, such as Mark’s odd dietary choices—a grilled cheese with American cheese and tomatoes?—and the sheer improbability of Jess regularly meeting Mark’s brother despite his city job. These inconsistencies took me right out of the story, failing to immerse me in the world of Bishop Mountain.
Memorable Moments and Notable Quotes
While my overall impression might lean toward the negative, some moments did shine through, such as Jess’s fiery declaration: “I’m still a red-headed mountain girl struggling to make my way in the world while he is the billionaire-in-the-making Marcus Evan Donovan.” It encapsulates the core struggle of their differing realities, although this tension wasn’t explored as deeply as it could have been.
In Conclusion
Ultimately, Marked might resonate with readers looking for a light escape into the world of billionaires and second chances, despite its shortcomings. For those who revel in romance tropes and can forgive a few glaring navigational errors, there may be entertainment to be had here. However, if you’re looking for depth, consistent pacing, and well-rounded character arcs, this might not be your cup of tea.
As I closed this book, I was left reflecting on the uneven ride it provided—a blend of intrigue and frustration that taught me a valuable lesson in expectation versus reality. Sometimes, it’s worth reading a book to understand what you don’t want in romance, and Marked definitely falls into that category for me. Happy reading, my fellow book lovers! You may want to tread carefully here.
For more reviews, head on over to Rather Bookish!
Discover more about Marked (The Boys of Bishop Mountain #1) on GoodReads >>
