Book Review: The Last Sister by Kendra Elliot
When I first picked up The Last Sister, I was excited. The premise hinted at secrets, suspense, and the kind of gritty character dynamics that often tug at my heartstrings. Kendra Elliot, known for her engaging storytelling, promised an enthralling ride through the twists and turns of crime and investigation. Unfortunately, the experience left me feeling like I was given a ticket to a rollercoaster ride that fell a bit flat, with several missed opportunities along the way.
The story revolves around the investigation of a brutal murder in a small town, introducing us to characters like Zander Wells, an FBI agent whose charm feels a bit too relaxed given the hauntings of his current case. As he navigates the tight-knit community, I found myself questioning the logical decisions he made—like how easily he mingled with townsfolk while working through a violent crime scene. Sure, building rapport is crucial for such investigations, but it felt unrealistic and at times, a tad comedic.
What struck me most about The Last Sister was the unevenness of the writing. Certain passages shone brightly, filled with emotion and compelling dialogue, while others left me scratching my head in confusion. It was as if the manuscript had been edited on a whim, swinging back and forth from polished segments to awkward phrasing. My frustration peaked when the author misused the possessive, leading us to believe characters were related in ways that simply weren’t true. Why were Emily Mills and Ava McClain being called sisters when they clearly weren’t? Such basic oversights pulled me out of the narrative, and I was left pondering what could have been with a more diligent editing process.
Despite its potential, the humor lurking in certain parts felt misplaced. I was expecting a serious crime thriller, but instead, Zander’s quirks and the baffling dialogues gave me the sense that I might be watching a spoof rather than a riveting investigation. For instance, Zander’s blunder about a suspect being armed simply because they were a suspect had me chuckling, albeit in disbelief. His uncanny, almost absurd bond with the community, allowing a civilian to trail behind him, only raised further eyebrows.
While secrets and lies are often the backbone of crime stories, the “lying by omission” theme felt overdone here. Characters withheld vital information under the guise of protecting one another, ultimately infantilizing those around them. The narrative could have thrived on mature dialogues instead of skirted around issues that directly affected their safety, which was frustrating to witness.
In essence, Kendra Elliot’s The Last Sister is rife with intriguing potential, yet it falters significantly in its execution. For readers who enjoy a blend of mystery peppered with unexpected humor, there might be some enjoyment here. However, if you seek a tightly knit thriller that grips you by the heart, you may want to look elsewhere. The experience made me nostalgic for the seamless storytelling I’ve found in other novels, underscoring how vital careful editing and cohesive character development can be.
In the end, while I appreciated the sparks of brilliance that emerged throughout the book, my advice would be to tread gently with anticipation. Whether you embrace the ride or end up disappointed like I did, The Last Sister certainly leaves an impression, but perhaps not the one we all hoped for.
Discover more about The Last Sister (Columbia River, #1; Callahan & McLane,… on GoodReads >>