A Symphony of Healing: My Thoughts on The Siren and the Star by Colby Cedar Smith
As someone who’s always been captivated by the intertwining of music and narrative, I was immediately drawn to Colby Cedar Smith’s The Siren and the Star. The idea of a novel-in-verse that bridges the story of two women separated by centuries yet connected through their musical journeys was simply irresistible. And let me tell you, this lush, lyrical exploration did not disappoint!
At its heart, The Siren and the Star weaves the stories of Luciana "Lula" Gabroni, a contemporary music student grappling with the aftermath of trauma, and Barbara Strozzi, a 17th-century Venetian composer and singer who defied the limitations of her society. From the moment I stepped into Lula’s world—a realm thick with anxiety and loss—the poignant weight of her experiences resonated with me deeply. When she discovers Barbara’s music during a visit to Venice, an echo of deep understanding reverberates through both their lives, a theme of reclaiming voice and agency that felt incredibly relevant.
What struck me most was how Smith masterfully distinguishes between her narrators. Lula’s voice, written in compressed, anxiety-laden verses, contrasted beautifully with Barbara’s flowing and sensual prose. This structural choice not only provided unique perspectives, but also mirrored their shared struggles against the expectations placed on them by society and their families. It’s a clever narrative device that enhanced my emotional connection to both characters—each one is fighting their own battle, and yet their stories harmonize so beautifully.
The pacing of the novel kept me fully engaged, and I found myself savoring each section as if it were a musical composition. Smith’s descriptions of Venice are as vivid as a painting, lush with emotion and atmosphere. Her portrayal of the city—full of misty canals and opulent salons—felt both timeless and immediate. I was particularly struck by the way the historical context infused the narrative with a sense of urgency and depth, especially in Barbara’s story, which hints at a feminist Cinderella tale bursting free from the constraints of patriarchy.
What I truly appreciated was how the book treated difficult topics, such as PTSD and violence, with the sensitivity they deserve. Instead of allowing these experiences to define Lula, Smith allows her to emerge resilient, supported by a chosen family and the art that binds her to Barbara. It’s a powerful reminder of the strength found in community and creative expression.
The music, too, is a character in itself. Smith writes music as if she plucks at heartstrings with every line—one particularly memorable moment that struck a chord with me was the description of a melody that "transcends language, reaching into the soul and pulling it into light." That resonance of art breaking barriers is unforgettable.
In conclusion, The Siren and the Star is more than just a captivating read; it’s a resonant piece that will speak to anyone who has ever felt silenced or lost. Its lyrical quality, historical depth, and emotional honesty create a reading experience that left me both introspective and uplifted. I highly recommend it to readers interested in female empowerment, historical fiction, and anyone who believes in the transformative power of art. This novel is a testament to the beautiful symphony of womanhood, creativity, and resilience—a book that utterly sings.
Discover more about The Siren and the Star on GoodReads >>